60 School Carnival Prize Ideas (That Kids Actually Like—and Won’t End Up in the Trash)

Skip the junky toys and try these fun, meaningful carnival prize ideas instead! 🖍️🪴 Includes food, art, nature, and activity-based prizes. #SustainableCarnival #SchoolFundraiser #CarnivalPlanning

If you’ve ever manned the prize table at a school carnival, you know the struggle is real: a mountain of plastic trinkets, a wave of sugar-hyped kids, and at least one whistle that gets “accidentally” blown into someone’s ear. 🎉

But it doesn’t have to be that way!

With a little planning and a focus on fun and practicality, you can stock your prize table with goodies that kids will love, parents will appreciate, and custodians won’t have to sweep up by 3pm.

In this guide, you’ll find smart, kid-approved carnival prize ideas—plus where to find them and what to avoid (spoiler alert: please don’t give out goldfish 🐟🚫).

Before we dive into the prize list, here are some quick tips for sourcing prizes that are safe, sustainable, and sanity-saving.

---

Where to Source Carnival Prizes

✅ Buy from a Reputable Wholesaler

Whether you’re ordering online or shopping locally, make sure your prizes come from a trusted seller. Look for items that meet government safety standards for toys—especially if you’re giving them to younger children. If the price seems way too good to be true, it probably is.

🙌 Ask for Parent Donations

You’d be amazed how many families have unopened toys, games, craft kits, or even party favors collecting dust in a closet. Around spring carnival time, ask parents to send in gently used or new items. (Pro tip: “Re-gifted” Christmas extras make fantastic prize additions!)

🤝 Reach Out to Local Businesses

Many small businesses are happy to support school events by donating gift cards, small products, or branded merchandise in exchange for a shoutout in your program or on event signage. Think toy shops, bookstores, hair salons, and even your local grocery store.

🐟 Why Live Animals Should Never Be Carnival Prizes

We know, we know—some of you might have fond memories of winning a little goldfish in a plastic bag at your school carnival. It might even be part of your childhood highlight reel. But here’s the thing: we know better now, and it’s time to leave that tradition in the past.

Giving away live animals—goldfish, turtles, frogs, or anything else—as prizes might seem like harmless fun, but it comes with real problems:

• Stress & Harm to the Animal: Carnival environments are noisy, hot, and chaotic. That’s not a safe or humane situation for any living creature.
• Immediate Burden on Parents: Surprise! You now need a tank, water conditioner, food, and time to keep this little guy alive. Not exactly the kind of prize most parents are thrilled to receive.
• Poor Outcomes for the Animal: At best, the fish gets rushed home in a panic and plopped into a salad bowl. At worst… flushed. Or swallowed. (It’s happened—Google it. Just maybe don’t after lunch.)

There are so many fun, kid-approved alternatives that don’t involve living beings. Gummy fish. Plush toys. Bubble wands. Seed bombs. All the joy—none of the guilt (or mess, or trauma).

So let’s be kind to animals, kind to parents, and kind to ourselves.
No goldfish. No live animals. Full stop

60 Thoughtful & Fun Carnival Prize Ideas

🎨 Art Supplies

Art-themed prizes are always a hit. They’re budget-friendly, screen-free, and give kids a quiet activity to enjoy after the carnival hype wears off. Bonus: they’re easy to find in bulk and rarely end up broken in the bottom of a backpack.

Prize Ideas:

• Mini coloring books
• Boxes of crayons
• Washable markers
• Colored pencils
• Sidewalk chalk
• Watercolor paint sets
• Sticker-by-number books
• Stencil sets
• Paint-with-water books
• DIY craft kits (bracelets, popsicle sticks, paper puppets)

🖍️ Tip: Look for multi-packs to split across prize levels—one jumbo crayon set can become 10 prizes!

---

🧩 Activities & Games

Great for keeping hands busy and kids engaged long after the booths shut down.

These are small but mighty—ideal for all ages and perfect for breaking up the sugar rush. Look for non-messy, compact items that don’t require supervision or batteries.

Prize Ideas:

• Slime tubs or putty (pre-made and sealed)
• Small puzzle cubes (like mini Rubik’s-style toys)
• Playing cards (Go Fish, Old Maid, Memory)
• Mini puzzles or puzzle books
• Bouncy balls
• Finger puppets
• Wind-up toys
• Model magic or mini tubs of Play-Doh
• Magic wands or “glow” items
• Bubble wands or bubble tubes

🧠 Want less plastic? Prioritize puzzles, clay, and activity kits over disposable toys.

✏️ Stationery & Trinkets

Tiny treasures kids actually use—and some they’ll proudly collect or trade with friends.

These are great for a prize table because they’re easy to display, lightweight, and super customizable by age group. You can make them even more exciting by bundling a few into themed mini prize bags.

Prize Ideas:

• Cute pencils (themed, sparkly, or scented!)
• Fun-shaped erasers
• Mini notepads or sticky note sets
• Sticker sheets or rolls
• Keychains (character-themed, plush, glow-in-the-dark)
• Gel pens or highlighter pens
• Enamel pins (great for backpacks!)
• Mini stampers
• Pop-its and fidget spinners
• Bookmarks (bonus if they’re funny or inspirational)

🖇️ Pro tip: Stationery bundles make perfect “medium” prize tier rewards and feel more special than a single item.

---

🍿 Food-Based Prizes

Treats that are easy to hand out, allergy-aware, and always popular.

If your school allows edible prizes, these are easy crowd-pleasers. Just be mindful of common allergies and dietary restrictions, and aim for individually packaged items whenever possible.

Prize Ideas:

• Bags of popcorn (plain or flavored)
• Mini cupcakes (individually wrapped if possible)
• Donuts or donut holes (use food-safe containers)
• Fruit snacks or fruit leathers
• Goldfish crackers
• Allergy-friendly granola bars
• Mini packs of pretzels or popcorn chips
• Lollipops or mini candy bars
• Juice boxes or flavored waters
• DIY snack coupons for the concession stand

🍬 Note: Always have a few allergy-free treat options marked clearly at the prize table.

🎟️ Experience-Based Prizes

These non-material rewards are pure excitement—no packaging required!

Experience-based prizes are a fantastic way to keep the fun going beyond the booth. They’re especially great for “big ticket” winners, or as an option kids can trade up to after earning multiple small wins.

Prize Ideas:

• Face painting pass
• Glitter tattoo or temporary tattoo voucher
• Bounce house entry ticket
• Fast pass to skip a line (great for games or food!)
• “Choose the next song” ticket at the DJ booth
• Photo booth ticket
• Pie-a-teacher pass (with adult approval!)
• Carnival “VIP” lanyard for the day
• Ice cream or snack bar coupon
• Extra punch or bonus spin at the prize wheel

🎫 Tip: Print custom coupons or punch cards to make these feel official and exciting.

---

🌱 Nature & Eco-Friendly Prizes

Fun, sustainable, and perfect for families who love a prize that grows with you.

These are ideal for Earth-conscious events or schools that want to reduce plastic waste. Bonus: they’re often inexpensive, unique, and educational too!

Prize Ideas:

• Seed packets (flowers, veggies, herbs)
• Wildflower seed bombs
• Mini succulents in pots
• Paint-your-own terracotta pots
• DIY bird feeder kits (kid-sized)
• Wooden yo-yos or tops
• Nature-themed sticker books
• Recycled paper notebooks
• Mini bug-catching kits (with a magnifier and jar)
• Beeswax crayon sets

🌼 Pair nature prizes with Earth Day or garden-themed booths for extra impact!

The prize table might be the last stop of the carnival, but it’s one of the first things kids remember—so let’s make it count! Choosing thoughtful, safe, and sustainable carnival prizes doesn’t have to be expensive or complicated. With a mix of creative ideas, donated goodies, and fun experiences, you can stock your prize booth with things kids actually want and parents won’t roll their eyes at.

Remember: safety first, skip the single-use plastic where you can, and under no circumstances—no goldfish. Ever. 🐟❌

Here’s to a prize table full of smiles (and zero whistles in the trash)!