Bake It, Sell It, Fund It: The Ultimate PTA Bake Sale Guide

How to Plan a Successful Bake Sale

Planning a bake sale can feel like a big task, but trust me, with a little organization and some teamwork, it can be a huge success—and dare I say, even fun! Whether raising funds for your school, a sports team, or a community project, this guide will help you pull it off like a pro. Grab a coffee, and let’s jump into the first steps of planning your bake sale: preparation and organization.

---

Get Prepped Like a Pro

Before anything else, you’ll want to start with a plan that keeps everything running smoothly. This is where you set yourself up for success and avoid those “oops, we forgot forks!” moments. Here’s how:

1. Create a Sign-Up Sheet
   Keep it simple but clear—add categories like cookies, cupcakes, savory treats, or allergy-friendly options. This way, you won’t end up with 50 trays of brownies and no lemon bars. Display the sheet somewhere visible or share it online for easy access.
2. Let Bakers Choose What They Bring
   Variety is key! Allow your volunteers to bake whatever they feel like making. This takes the pressure off you and makes sure you have a fun mix of classic favorites and unique creations at the bake sale.
3. Ingredient Lists are a Must
   Ask your bakers to include an ingredient list with their goodies. This helps with allergy concerns and gives shoppers peace of mind. Plus, it’s a simple way to make your bake sale feel more professional.
4. Package Everything Individually
   Trust me, you don’t want to spend the day slicing cakes or portioning cookies. Pre-packaging also avoids cross-contamination and keeps everything neat and hygienic. Bakers can use zip-top bags, plastic wrap, or cupcake boxes to make their treats grab-and-go friendly.
5. Separate Nut Items
   Designate a clearly labeled section for any treats with nuts to avoid cross-contamination. You want everyone to feel safe and included.
6. Be Ready to Supplement
   If your sign-up sheet looks sparse or is missing key items (like those breakfast treats for a morning event), you can always grab some store-bought goodies to fill in the gaps. There is no shame in that!
7. Dress Up the Table
   A sprinkle of powdered sugar or some fun decorations can work wonders. Bring a shaker of powdered sugar or extra sprinkles to refresh items that might need a little pizzazz.

---

Must-Have Supplies You Can’t Forget

Now that you’ve got your bakers in gear, let’s talk about the stuff you’ll need to bring. You don’t want to scramble for napkins or run out of small bills halfway through the sale. Here’s your must-have list for a smooth event:

1. Forks, Napkins, and Bags
   Think about your shoppers! Many people will want to nibble on their purchases right away or take several treats home. Having forks and napkins on hand makes things easy for them.
2. A Cash Box with a Float
   Start the day with plenty of coins and small bills to make change. A cash box keeps everything secure and organized.
3. Signage for Pricing
   Even if bakers set their prices, it’s up to you to make sure they’re displayed. Use fun, colorful labels or signs to catch shoppers’ eyes.
4. Shelf-Stable Milk
   Here’s a pro tip: having individual milk cartons (bonus points if they’re cold) can boost your sales. Not everyone will want to wait to eat their treats, and milk is the perfect pairing for cookies or cake.
5. Backup Supplies
   Tape, scissors, pens, and spare signs are lifesavers for last-minute fixes. Trust me, you’ll thank yourself later for packing these.

Shop our Bake Sale Essentials on Amazon

---

This is just the start of a successful bake sale, but as you can see, a little prep goes a long way. Next, we’ll talk about how to market your bake sale, attract shoppers, and make sure everything sells like hotcakes!

Crowd-Pleasing Treats That Always Sell

Here’s the fun part: figuring out what treats to include! Bake sales are at their best when there’s a variety of delicious options. A little something for everyone will make shoppers happy and boost your sales. Here are some top-performing ideas to get you started:

1. The Classics
   Cookies, brownies, cupcakes, and bars are the backbone of any great bake sale. They’re easy to package, portable, and always a hit. Rice Krispies treats and dipped pretzel rods (with sprinkles, of course) are also crowd-pleasers.
2. Mini Treats
   Anything mini flies off the table. Mini cheesecakes, bite-sized brownies, or mini muffins are perfect for those who want to sample a treat without committing to a full-size portion.
3. Savory Options
   Don’t forget the savory snacks! Items like cheese and ham scones or mini empanadas can be a nice change from all the sweets. These are especially popular later in the day when people might be craving something less sugary.
4. Allergy-Friendly and Vegan Treats
   Be sure to include a few items that cater to common dietary needs. Factory-made, individually packaged peanut-free, tree nut-free, or vegan snacks work perfectly. You can also ask a volunteer to bake gluten-free cookies or nut-free granola bars.
5. Something for the Kids
   Anything colorful or sprinkled will be a hit with kids. Cupcakes with frosting swirls, cookies dusted with powdered sugar, or rice cereal treats shaped into fun designs are guaranteed to sell out fast.
6. Unique or Novelty Items
   If one of your bakers has a special recipe or creative idea—like jelly cups, flavored raisins, or themed cupcakes—highlight it! These fun, standout items often attract curious shoppers.

---

Spread the Word and Get Shoppers Lining Up

Now that you know what to bake, it’s time to spread the word! A well-advertised bake sale is half the battle. Use these tips to ensure a steady stream of shoppers throughout the event:

1. Start Promoting Early
   Get the word out a week or two before the sale. Use social media, the school newsletter, or even good old-fashioned posters to let everyone know the when, where, and why. Make sure to highlight any special or unique items to create buzz.
2. Decorate the Table
   First impressions matter, so make your setup as inviting as possible. Use bright tablecloths, cute signs, and maybe even a banner with the event name. Use decorations that match the theme if it’s a themed bake sale (like a holiday or school spirit theme).
3. Display Sample Items
   Put one of each treat in a clear display case or on a platter so shoppers can see what’s inside the packaging. People are more likely to buy something if they can see what they’re getting.
4. Encourage Word of Mouth
   Ask volunteers and parents to share the event details with friends and family. You might even offer a small incentive for bringing in more shoppers, like a free treat for every referral.
5. Use Eye-Catching Signage
   Big, bold signs are your best friend. Include details like pricing, allergy information, and the reason for the fundraiser. For example, “All proceeds support our school playground!” gives people a reason to feel good about their purchase.

With a great mix of treats and a little effort to drum up excitement, your bake sale will have people lining up to shop. Next, we’ll share some day-of tips and tricks to keep everything running smoothly and maximize your sales!

Smart Pricing Tips to Maximize Sales

When it comes to pricing at your bake sale, flexibility and clear communication are key. You want to make it easy for shoppers to know what they’re paying while ensuring your volunteers aren’t stressed. Here’s how to nail it:

1. Let Bakers Set Their Prices
   Simplify the process by allowing your bakers to price their treats. Most people have a good sense of what their items are worth. As the organizer, you can create signage for each item to keep things consistent and easy for shoppers to see.
2. Bundle for Bigger Sales
   People love a deal! Offer discounts for bundles, like “3 cookies for $5” or “Buy 2 bars, get 1 free.” Bundles encourage customers to grab more than one item, which is a win for your fundraiser.
3. Have a Clear-Out Sale
   Toward the end of the event, group items together for a reduced price to clear your table. A “fill a bag for $5” sale can be a great way to offload remaining treats and give shoppers a sense of value.
4. Include a Donations Jar
   Some people may not want to buy anything but still want to support your cause. A labeled jar for cash donations gives them a chance to contribute. You’ll be surprised how much this simple addition can raise!
5. Make Change Simple
   Start the day with a well-stocked float of coins and small bills. It’s frustrating for everyone if you can’t break a $20, so plan accordingly.

---

Set Up for Success on Bake Sale Day

A little organization goes a long way when setting up your bake sale. With a few thoughtful touches, you’ll create a smooth, stress-free experience for shoppers and volunteers alike.

1. Arrive Early for Setup
   Give yourself plenty of time to arrange the table, check supplies, and make last-minute tweaks before the first customer arrives. A well-prepped table looks more inviting and professional.
2. Organize by Category
   Group treats into sections like cookies, cupcakes, savory snacks, and allergy-friendly options. This makes browsing easy and keeps the table looking tidy.
3. Label Everything Clearly
   Use large, readable labels for each item, including the name, price, and any important notes like “contains nuts” or “gluten-free.” This saves time answering questions and helps shoppers make quick decisions.
4. Designate Volunteer Roles
   Assign specific tasks to each volunteer, like restocking the table, handling money, or helping customers. A clear division of labor keeps things running smoothly and ensures no one feels overwhelmed.
5. Prepare for Walk-Around Events
   If your bake sale is part of a larger event (like a fair or carnival), focus on portable treats that are easy to eat while walking. Avoid anything that requires utensils or is overly messy.
6. Keep Backup Supplies Handy
   Have a small kit with tape, pens, scissors, and spare signs ready for quick fixes. You never know when you’ll need them!
7. Provide Bags for Purchases
   Offer small paper or plastic bags so shoppers can easily carry their items home. It’s a small touch that makes a big difference.

With everything organized and thoughtfully laid out, your bake sale will be inviting, efficient, and enjoyable for everyone. Next up, we’ll share some post-sale tips and how to keep the momentum going for your next event!

Wrap It Up and Celebrate Your Success

Once your bake sale is over, there’s still some work to do, but it’s all about wrapping things up neatly and celebrating your success. Here’s how to finish strong:

1. Donate Leftovers
   If you have unsold items, consider donating them to school staff, volunteers, or a local charity. It’s a fantastic way to spread the goodwill even further.
2. Tally Your Earnings
   Count the cash and calculate your total earnings. Make a note of which items sold best to help you plan for future events. You’ll probably notice some trends that can guide your next bake sale (hint: kids love sprinkles and mini treats!).
3. Thank Volunteers and Donors
   A quick thank-you email or a shout-out on social media can go a long way. Acknowledge everyone who contributed—bakers, shoppers, and helpers alike—and let them know how much was raised for your cause. Gratitude fosters a strong community!
4. Gather Feedback
   Ask volunteers and customers for their thoughts. What worked? What could be improved? Honest feedback will help make your next bake sale even better.
5. Pack Up Supplies for Next Time
   Keep reusable items like signage, leftover forks and napkins, and any unused cash box supplies together in one place. Future-you will thank you for being so organized!

---

You’ve Totally Got This!

And that’s it—you’ve officially planned and executed a fantastic bake sale! Whether it’s your first or your fifteenth, these tips will help you stay organized, boost sales, and make the event enjoyable for everyone involved. The key is to embrace the fun, let your creativity shine, and lean on your team of bakers and volunteers.

Now it’s time to celebrate your hard work! Treat yourself to one of those leftover cookies (you’ve earned it!) and pat yourself on the back for pulling off an event that supports your school or community in such a sweet way.

If you found this guide helpful, don’t forget to save it on Pinterest or share it with your fellow bake sale planners. Here’s to many more successful bake sales ahead!